Score: 3

"Expected better from you"

submission: Still Alive - Portal

date: December 10, 2007

Music videos need an interesting combination of audio and video in order to keep the end result enjoyable. Unfortunately this doesn't have that. The song is awesome, that's for sure, but props for that go to Coulton.

The accompanying visuals don't nearly match up to what could have been done--there's very little animation in this flash. Almost all of it is a pixel face lip-syncing to the music, and that's boring. The few parts that were animated were pretty good though, but they took up maybe less than 10% of the entire video. It hurts the end result.

Chances are you should have waited a while longer to come up with better ideas first.

Score: 10

"Couldn't have been any better."

submission: Flash Comedy Extravaganza

date: June 4, 2006

So... so... SO right. I'm more than happy to know that this has been made. There should be more movies like this to counter the flash garbage pollution on the net. A+

Score: 3

"It's been done."

submission: Pacman - The Movie

date: May 1, 2006

Actually, the IMDB link's a farce. There is no Pac-Man movie, the link was added by a IMDB viewer. Funny how something released at the beginning of the month is copied at the end of the month while the actual IMDB link's been around since 2005 without a word spoken of it.

Score: 6

"You're getting better."

submission: The Rotting

date: February 3, 2006

You've been gradually improving and I commend you for that. The drawings are better than before and so is the style. You definitely managed to pull off old timey.

The only trouble I have with it is that it feels somewhat anticlimactic compared to the first Silent Film, which was meant to be wacky. This is a neat animation and all--definitely one of your better ones, but compared to episode 1 it wasn't very funny. I think you should go for 3.

All in all you put in a good effort, so you get hats off and all that stuff... TIME TRAVELLER :{

Score: 4

"My ve®sion's bette® :}"

submission: 8-Bit Theater Part 5

date: December 26, 2005

...And it was finished a yea® ea®lie®, too. Lawsuit! LAWSUIT!!

The lesson is lea®ned. Even if you totally waste a gino®mous amount of time, you ©annot stop the innundation of but©he®ing known as sp®ite fanmovies--and mo®eove®, you ©an't easily make something funny when the®e isn't ANY a©tual humo® to wo®k with (o® if the mate®ial is nea®ly 5 yea®s old and al®eady seen by the majo®ity of the viewe®s). In pa®t, this is why the sequen©e of events o©©u®ing in this movie was best left as p®int sin©e it's mo®e o® less a long-winded ®ant about ®PG stat te®ms (whi©h was, by fa®, the wo®st pa®t of the enti®e 8-Bit se®ies... and I love the ©omi©), but I did noti©e the fast-fo®wa®d pa®t--good ©all, I hope that's ®eal.

I do give you guys ©®edit fo® t®ying to imp®ove on the visuals. Lots of the ext®a stuff helped move things along a lot mo®e than in p®evious episodes when it was just long tweens of one o® two sp®ites fo® seve®al se©onds at a time. I noti©ed Housemaste® AND SEVE®AL OTHE® FAMILIA® IDEAS.

Summed up, this ©ame out as good as it ©ould've and it's bette® than the olde® episodes, but I stand by the belief that it shouldn't have been made in the fi®st pla©e.

Score: 10

"Brilliant"

submission: littleFoot

date: November 8, 2005

The graphics and overall animation are spectacular and there's no other way to say it.

It becomes painfully clear just how much time and devotion you invest into your work and it's a stunning example to animators everywhere.

One of my favorite parts of your works is that everything has such a lively sense of 'freedom'. It's all about the atmosphere that's set in the world you've created.

Rock on!

Score: 3

"Disappointing."

submission: All NG Fads Die!!! 3!!!

date: October 18, 2005

At first I wondered why you would bother to slam the 'popular flash characters' yet skipped over most of the REAL losers on this site. Let's just go with 'putting in well-known characters everybody likes MIGHT make others enjoy our movie.'

Seriously. Throwing in a bunch of popular characters and mixing them with excessive violence is what terrible NG authors do best. Rather than coming up with a CLEVER insult or anything entertaining, you've resorted to lots and lots of poorly animated death and borrowed characters to throw onto the garbage pile known as NG Collabs. The only part I liked in this entire movie was the part where the epic kiss sequence got fast-forwarded and the two characters bumped their heads together. THAT was good. Throwing in a bunch of Barneys tweening around awkwardly for YET ANOTHER MATRIX PARODY was not.

All that you really did was indulge in the most prominent and irritating cliche on this site, and that defeats the purpose of making this movie in the first place.

Score: 7

"Pretty good!"

submission: Liu Kang's Crossover

date: October 18, 2005

For a sprite movie you handled this very well and managed not to make it entirely full of cliches that just about every other sprite movie has--you came up with your OWN ideas. Good work!

Score: 7

"This is your best movie to date"

submission: Silent Film

date: September 29, 2005

Up until now hardly anything's been watchable, but this time you've made something that made me laugh a bit. The graphics and animation could've used a bit more work, but the overall idea is good. I liked it. Good work.

Score: 8

"Very nice"

submission: No Man's Land Flash Anime

date: September 8, 2005

I really like the graphics--those are superb, but I seriously think you should've spent a lot more time on actual animation. A majority of what's in this is just excessive loop/cycled animation redundancy--a short 1 second looped animation makes itself obvious when played 15 times in a row--i.e., the crow at the beginning, the bartender with his toothpick, and the hero looped their animations at least 10 times without much regard to timing. Putting that together with the general lack of movement and overuse of tweens just makes it boring and exanimate. It should be an animation--not a powerpoint presentation.

Excellent graphics, but as a flash animation I think it's kinda overrated. This would've been better off as the manga.